Friday, January 27, 2012
Blog Post 3
“Second Variety” was a very good story. In my opinion, the moral of it
is that the creation of atomic weapons that can bring about the apocalypse will
one day surely bring about the apocalypse. All it takes is one action, just one
press of a button to initiate it. Sometimes, however, I must admit that I
disagree with this. I definitely do not believe the U.S. will fire one off
first again (even though we HAD to do so during WWII, despite what some people
may say). I don’t even think the governments of countries like Iran and North
Korea would. Why? Because even though the dictators who control those countries
may be complete assholes to their own people, they’re definitely not stupid. If
anything, they’re greedy as hell. Most people in power, including those in our
own country, care only about two things: power and wealth. If they were to fire
off a nuke today (as opposed to the weak ones dropped at Hiroshima and
Nagasaki) and start a chain reaction of countries firing off nukes at one
another in the process, then they wouldn’t have the means to continue acquiring
more power and wealth because the majority of the people on the planet would be
dead. Sure they (the world’s rulers) could travel to the moon, or move
underground, but with everyone gone, is their money really worth anything? Do
they really possess the kind of power they had when 7 billion people roamed the
planet? Obviously not. In the advent of nuclear technology, people used to say
that these bombs would be able to deter war. That too obviously hasn’t turned
out to be the case. If anything, the destructive power of nuclear bombs simply
deter people from using them. With
that said, I think “Second Variety” is a great story. Sure it’s entertaining,
but its message is also one that should definitely be heeded. The reason I say
this is because if a nuclear weapon (or codes) was to get in the hands of the
wrong person, say, a religious fanatic who doesn’t care about power or wealth
or anything this world as to offer, then we’re all definitely screwed. From
that standpoint, I couldn’t be in more agreement with the moral of this story.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Matt,
ReplyDeleteGood and interesting thoughts. I'm glad that "Second Variety" stirred you up so much! I think this kind of energy is exactly what SF as a genre seeks to create.
Remember that while various characters in a short story may express a moral ("I don't think you should have done that"), the story as a whole usually is more complicated than a simple moral, and I think your discussion of nuclear politics here bears that out. There's no simple answer, even in your very straightforward analysis, about how to comfortably and easily live in a world with such weapons. So mind the difference b/t theme and moral.
I'm interested in your assessment of how nuclear weapons don't preclude war, but they do preclude using those weapons in the resultant wars. Interesting thoughts.